girl,i know exactly what your talking about i had that problem for SO long. i would put my eyeliner on in the morning and by noon i looked like a hooker with my eyeliner like smudged everywhere. i tried everything liquid was extremely hard to put on and very harshly dark, pencils seemed to come off very quickly, and i just couldn't find something that would stay on my eyes. Finally i just asked my mom (she does make - up professionally at mac) and she said if you look at an eyeliners ingredients if its has an oil base in it it will come off then she asked me if i was up to trying pressed powder eyeliner. all you do it buy the eyeliner it looks sort of like black eyeshadow but its eyeliner and use an eyeliner brush to apply it. It really works well but, its a little hard to apply the first couple of times. hope i helped

__________________
Yahoo! Answers