The most overrated celebrity out there right now is Paris Hilton. She has no talent what so ever. But if I had to answer between the 2 you have mentioned it would be Jessica Simpson. At least Lindsay despite the problems she has been going through, has had some praise for her acting abilities and she can sing as well. Most noteworthy is from the movie "Bobby". Jessica plain & simple dosen't have much brains and can't act worth a crap. After all just go ask your local "Chicken of the Sea".

__________________
Yahoo!